Apparently quoting is not working for me right now ...
Jamie, When you get an opportunity, see if you can find some long flat roads at 35, 45, and 55mph. Set the cruise control to those speeds and (with a warm engine) see what the instant fuel mileage reading says. Mine pegs 40mpg at 35 and 45. 55mph I am usually around 35mpg. 65 is usually right around 26-28mpg. After 65, this 4500lb brick’s gas mileage proceeds to fall off a cliff. If your readings aren’t somewhat close to mine, all I can think of is that the O2 sensors in your car are somehow not calibrated correctly, but I find that extremely unlikely.
I don’t know for sure, but I don’t believe the trip mpg readings takes remote start/warmup into account. So it may say you are getting better gas mileage when you let your car warm up than you are actually getting. It wouldn’t be putting the 5 minutes of burning gas at 0mpg into the equation.
As far as turbo engines and gas mileage go, the mpg benefit is only there when you are not in boost. Once you hit boost, you are guzzling gas just like a larger engine.