I'm not here to knock on anyones personal choices for either exterior or interior color choices. I know black will show more loose particles like my kid's pretzel crumbs, goldfish pieces and dry cereal bits due to contrast but my concern is more about scuffs and stains. My wife's current car has gray leather and after 170,000 miles it still looks great but doesn't look as clean as it should. I condition and clean it very often and manage to get a lot of filth off but when finished it still looks a little dingy and no matter how hard I scrub while cleaning and conditioning, it doesn't have that new and clean look. The black leather is going to hide mild scuffs and staining much better than the lighter colors and why we are migrating away from a light color to black. I've only had black interiors in all my cars since I was 17 and want to continue that tradition.
When we bought our Redline Vue 9 years ago, the only leather option was gray so we had to go with it. My wife ruled out the new Acura RDX because you can only get a beige interior with the white exterior so we went with the Edge since black was an option.
As for the Sienna interior, I'm not sure if there are any variations based on the exterior you choose but we looked at a white Edge and it had a 2 tone interior. I just searched "Ford Edge Sienna Interior" and found another white Edge and it also has a 2 tone interior. Murphie says his isn't 2 tone but as you can see by the attached photos, the 2 tone Sienna interior does exist in the wild. The dealership that has this Edge listed for sale has the attached photos labeled and you can see it is a White Platinum Edge in Limited trim. When you open the doors you are greeted by dark brown seating surfaces but the sides of the seats and the backs are black.
In my opinion, this is not an attractive combination and just doesn't make sense. I love a well done 2 tone interior like seen on the Sports or SEL appearance where you have suede inserts of a slightly different color for a bit of contrast and the rest of the seats and seat backs are consistent but how Ford split the color differences on the seats combined with the white exterior ruins it for me.
You all can make your own decisions based on the photos of the Sienna interior and I would like to know if there are different variations because I saw a white Edge with 2 tone (which I believe was a Limited model), posted a white Edge with 2 tone (also a Limited model) but Murphie says his isn't. Maybe the Sienna differs in trim levels if it isn't based on exterior color. Maybe the Limited models are 2 tone and the SEL models are solid brown?
Murphie, please let us know your trim level and if you can post a few pics of your interior that would be great.
Mark